Tag Archives: rebecca solnit

In phony looting news…

The cBS headline: “Small Amount of Looting at Texas Blast Site,” follows a script ably dissected by social comentator Rebecca Solnit on how authorities promote division among residents of a disaster area to enhance their power at the expense of community feeling and cooperation. DRUDGE cooperates by enhancing the tale with the headline: “Looters Raid Homes.”

The original cBS story depends on the nebulous quote of one police sergeant who can’t get specific because he apparently has nothing to be specific about. Ah, but the coppers have things well in hand. “Very secure” now they say, keeping even homeowners away from their damaged homes.

Which, of course, also is going on in Watertown, Mass, where postal worker Michael Demirdjian has been barred from his home, which contradicts the WaPo’s headline that residents have been told to stay home behind locked doors. This supposedly to aid the search for one bombing suspect, though I suspect “the authorities” there are simply reveling in their ability to order people around—shutting down schools, businesses and whole neighborhoods.

Looks pretty hysterical from afar. And counterproductive since, as Solnit makes plain with historical evidence, it turns people who might have helped in the search into passive sheep either isolated from one another or herded from one place to the next by armed and strutting bureaucrats who are absolute strangers to the area and in the best of circumstances couldn’t find their posteriors with both hands.

UPDATE:  Forget TSA’s airport excesses, the bureaucrats have turned Boston into a “Prison City.”

MORE:  Life in the Police State “…as convoys of heavily armed officers and troops arrived by the hour.” You couldn’t pay me to live in Massachusetts.

The good that comes with disasters

Whenever disaster renews itself, as it inevitably does in the form of hurricanes, tornadoes, floods, etc., I’m reminded of the many such events I had to “cover” in my 35 years as a print and electronic journalist and my recurrent discovery of the extraordinary degree to which ordinary people unselfishly pitched in to form a “community” to help each other.

It was a phenomenon that seldom got reported because it didn’t fit the formula my editors insisted be followed. They were, though they never admitted it, as Stephen Clark has written: “…merely courtiers to the political and cultural powers incumbent in society.”

Thus government and elite solutions were their narrative, though, generally, it wasn’t until government arrived that things really started to bog down, tempers frayed and so forth.

Bureaucrats, with their inflexible rules and authoritarian attitudes, backed by armed national guard and police with itchy trigger fingers stringing their yellow tape everywhere and keeping people from their damaged homes, just naturally promote frustration and isolation.

So I wasn’t surprised to see Rebecca Solnit’s book A Paradise Built In Hell: The Extraordinary Communities that Arise in Disaster —though I’m almost three years late in ordering it in Kindle form. It uses history lessons as varied as the 1909 San Francisco earthquake and the aftermath of 9-11 to persuasively debunk the usual elitist attitude that disaster brings human chaos, looting, murder, and so on: the cliche stuff you always see in movies and in most dystopian novels.

Stuff I can’t watch or read without wincing, because I know it’s mostly a pile of lies, as Solnit testifies:

“Part of the stereotypical image is that we’re either wolves or we’re sheep. We’re either devouring babies raw and tearing up grandmothers with our bare hands, or we’re helpless and we panic and mill around like idiots in need of Charlton Heston men in uniforms with badges to lead us. I think we’re neither, and the evidence bears that out.”

It certainly does.  Solnit is a self-proclaimed “progressive activist” but she’s one whose condemnation of Communist oppression shocks the Marxist left and she tells a valuable story of a kind of utopian community spontaneously arising in times of collapse.

Via Instapundit.