Category Archives: Library

Slaughter at Goliad

I finished this one last night, sandwiched in between the first and second volumes of U.S. Grant’s memoirs, and it was well worth the buy and the read. It’s billed as the most comprehensive look at the massacre, and I’d go along with that, though I haven’t read many others. Especially interesting is the section on weapons, which explains how so many of the American volunteers killed so many Mexican soldados in the Battle of Coleto, while they survived, and how the few survivors of of the massacre got away: the Mexican Brown Bess flintlock muskets were rendered poorer by weak, field-made powder.

I’ve seen several descriptions of how Fannin, who was executed last, supposedly asked not to be shot in the face but was, anyhow. Author Jay Stout quotes from the only eyewitness account, available at this site at Texas A&M, that Fannin actually asked only that the Mexican muskets not be held so close to his face that it receive powder burns, but he was disregarded. A strange sort of vanity, either way. You can find a good deal of the background material Stout cites here and at the A&M site. His bibliography is worth having by itself, and much of it also is online. Despite recent efforts to get the Mexican government to return the flag of the New Orleans Greys, about half of whom were murdered at Goliad, I agree with Stout that it belongs in Mexico, but wish that it would be put on display or, at least, photographed for public view.

Good as Stout’s book is, I must reiterate, that if you can only afford/read one book on the Texas Revolution, Stephen Hardin’s Texian Illiad is still the best.

Moment of Truth in Iraq

I was waiting for a good moment to buy Michael Yon’s book about Iraq, and Michael Totten’s revealing review is the one. The fact that the book is already in its second printing and currently No. 167 on Amazon’s bestseller list also is encouraging.

MORE: Cobb has an interesting take on it, from quotes from Yon’s changed-his-mind-on-Iraq publisher, to Cobb’s angry responses to some commenters. As he says: lead, follow or get the hell out of the way. 

Personal Memoirs of U.S. Grant

I finished volume one, having learned a few things I didn’t know. I enjoyed Grant’s direct, detailed style, without the usual flowery to-do of the 1880s. No wonder the memoir is considered a classic.

Hand grenades, for instance. I seem to remember a reference to them before, in one of the many books I’ve read by or about Civil War participants. But Grant tells me they were used by the Confederates in defense of Vicksburg. This site shows one at the bottom of the page, with a paper streamer designed to make it land on the percussion cap in the front to fire it. The Union had them, also.

Exploding musket-balls, now, I never heard of those. "…the wound was terrible," writes Grant who says Union troops also encountered them at Vicksburg. Various Web sites show the ex-Confederates denied using them, but accused the Union of doing so. It’s hard to imagine how to make one.

One of Grant’s interesting points: The South had a great advantage at the beginning of the war in that they had close to forty percent of the Nation’s trained soldiers. And because they had no standing army, those soldiers had to find service with their own state units, meaning "The whole loaf was leavened." The Union’s trained soldiers were largely concentrated in the regular army alone.

Good book. I recommend it. On to volume two.

Grant’s memoirs

I was browsing an Australian army list of military histories when I saw a reference to U.S. Grant’s memoirs, written hastily as he was dying of throat cancer in 1885, yet praised ever after as a literary masterpiece. I ordered the two-volume set in paperback from Amazon, and look forward to reading it. I’d thought of doing so, after recently reading a new more-candid look at R.E. Lee, but had forgotten.

Iron Man or wimp?

Hollyweird either does it again: "[M]ust we be tricked into sitting through another America-as-root-of-all-evil message?" Or it doesn’t: "Iron Man is not a pacifist movie, and it bends over backwards to be pro-military and pro-government, even in the midst of speeches about how weapons are evil." It’s a battle of the reviews. You decide. Not me. I already hate the sticky floors, and Mr. B. has enough fantasy in his life as it is.

The Best of the Simpsons

"Oooh, so Mother Nature needs a favor?! Well maybe she should have thought of that when she was besetting us with droughts and floods and poison monkeys! Nature started the fight for survival, and now she wants to quit because she’s losing. Well I say, hard cheese." — Mr. Burns

More where this one came from, here

The Irish Brigade

Reading the History of the 29th Massachusettes Infantry Regiment, 1861-65, last night, I came to the part, in the summer of 1862, where they were assigned to the Irish Brigade. The 29th went through the battle of Antietam, or Sharpsburg, with the Irish. But they were transferred to another brigade right before Fredericksburg in early December. Putting the book aside for a bit, I went Web wandering and chanced upon this touching clip from Gods and Generals, at Southern Appeal, on the Irish Brigade’s fateful charge at Fredericksburg. It took about fifty percent casualties. The 29th was luckily held in reserve throughout the battle.